Wednesday 9 November 2011

Custom reference resolver tutorial : creating a grammar


Introduction

In my previous blog entry, I presented an example on the new reference resolver add-on of ExtVal. It was able to read from a property from a MBean and use that value for validation.
As it was designed as a Reference Resolver, you had to specify a parameter at the cross field validation annotation of ExtVal where you needed the resolver. This is not friendly if you have designed some kind of resolver that you would use on a lot of locations.  Therefore the add-on has foreseen the option to create a new Reference Grammar. In this text I'll explain you how you can convert a reference resolver to a reference grammar.

Coding it

Basically, there are 2 small differences between a Reference Resolver and a Reference Grammar and you can use almost the same code in both situations. You only need to structure it a bit different.  Besides the registration of your grammar with the ExtVal add-on, see further, you should extend from the AbstractReferenceGrammar class. This class has a type parameter that needs to be specified.  In our case, it is just a simple object that holds the bean and property name. If you remember from my previous text, we invented a new grammar 'mbean@property' and the object just holds the 2 parts of the grammar (before and after the @-sign).
Your grammar has to implement 4 methods, so the empty grammar looks like this

@InvocationOrder(100)
public class MBeanGrammar extends AbstractReferenceGrammar
{

    @Override
    public void initGrammar()
    {
    }

    @Override
    protected boolean targetNotCompatibleWithGrammar(String targetValue)
    {
    }

    @Override
    protected MBeanGrammarData determineReference(String targetValue, MetaDataEntry metadataEntry)
    {
    }

    @Override
    public ReferencedValue resolveReference(MBeanGrammarData targetValue, MetaDataEntry metadataEntry)
    {
    }
}

where the (MBeanGrammarData object holds the bean and property name the user specified.

The initGrammar method is called when you register the grammar with the add-on.  You can use this interception point to do any initialization required to have a proper function of the grammar.  In our case we grab a reference to the MBean server we will be using for the resolving of the value.  Important thing to remember is that this method is just executed once.
When the ExtVal add-on encounters an annotation related to the cross field validation feature, it will ask to all the grammars if it can handle the specified reference.  Our implementation should return false for the targetNotCompatibleWithGrammar method when it contains the @-sign (our grammar can handle the reference) and true when we don't know it (like some EL-reference).  The first grammar that says that it can handle, will be used by the add-on.  How is the order determined? Grammars can be annotated with @InvocationOrder and the value you specify determines the order.  The default grammars (JavaBean and EL) have values of 950 and 1000.  So when we specify a value of 100, our new grammar is the first to be contacted to resolve the reference.
If we have a reference that we should handle, the add-on calls the determineReference method next. There we have the opportunity to parse the reference according to the grammar.  In our case it is just splitting the reference around the @-sign and put it into the MBeanGrammarData instance.

As a last step, the resolveReference method is called where we get the MBeanGrammarData instance we prepared in the previous step and we need to resolve the reference.  In our case we contact the MBean server, ask for the correct bean and extract the value of the property.  That value is wrapped nicely into the ReferencedValue and returned.

So the main difference is that the reference resolver contained all the logic in the resolveReference method and in the grammar version, we have the functionality split into 4 methods. You can find the code here.

Configuration

This is an additional step we need to do to integrate our grammar in the ExtVal add-on.  With the following 2 lines, placed in a startupListener, the Reference Grammar is registered and ready to use.

 ExtValContext extValContext = ExtValContext.getContext();
        extValContext.getModuleConfiguration(AdvancedCrossValidationAddonConfiguration.class).addReferenceGrammar(new MBeanGrammar());


Testing it

This version behaves exactly the same as our previous example, so I refer to the other text on how you can test it.

Conclusion

As easy it was to create a Reference Resolver, as easy it is to create a reference Grammar.  The grammar has the advantage that you don’t have to specify a parameter at the cross field validation annotation. But on the other side, if you only using it on a few locations, the add-on will ask your code for every reference, if you understand it.  So based on the concrete situation you have to decide what you need, a resolver or a reference.